Mix crushed Nutter Butter’s and butter together in a bowl until moist. Press into 10 inch deep pie pan. Freeze crust 10 minutes to firm.
In a mixer, beat cream cheese, powdered sugar, milk, vanilla, & 8 ounces of Cool Whip until blended. Spread 1/2 mixture over the crust.
Place chopped Peanut Butter cups over layer 1. Freeze 5 minutes.
Combine remaining mixture from layer 1, brown sugar, peanut butter, and remaining Cool Whip in mixer, blending well. Spread over filling.
Decorate with Cool Whip and add a sprinkle of crushed peanuts and chopped peanut butter cups.
Refrigerate 8 hours before serving.

Kitchen-Friendly View

Nutrition Facts

Per Serving Per 100 g

Amount Per 1 Serving
Calories	2777.43 Kcal (11629 kJ)
Calories from fat	1983.9 Kcal
		% Daily Value*
Total Fat	220.43g	339%
Cholesterol	115.24mg	38%
Sodium	2277.54mg	95%
Potassium	1856.89mg	40%
Total Carbs	191.44g	64%
Sugars	100.18g	401%
Dietary Fiber	28.15g	113%
Protein	85.63g	171%
Vitamin C	0.5mg	1%
Vitamin A	0.1mg	2%
Iron	11mg	61%
Calcium	301.9mg	30%

Amount Per 100 g
Calories	524.32 Kcal (2195 kJ)
Calories from fat	374.52 Kcal
		% Daily Value*
Total Fat	41.61g	339%
Cholesterol	21.76mg	38%
Sodium	429.95mg	95%
Potassium	350.55mg	40%
Total Carbs	36.14g	64%
Sugars	18.91g	401%
Dietary Fiber	5.31g	113%
Protein	16.17g	171%
Vitamin C	0.1mg	1%
Iron	2.1mg	61%
Calcium	57mg	30%

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
Find out how many calories should you eat.

Tastes

salty
savory
bitter
sweet

Search recipes
by ingredients

Construct & Analyze
Your Recipe

Analyze

Try this similar recipes

Peanut Butter Proposal Pie

Nutter butter sandwich cookies, crushed fine and 10 more..
Oreo Pudding

Cream cheese, room temperature, Powdered sugar, Milk and 5 more..
Frosted Sugar Cookie Bars

Sugar, Butter, softened, Cream cheese, softened, Egg and 11 more..
Dessert Pizza

Sugar cookie mix, Egg, Butter, melted, Cream cheese and 7 more..
Dirt Cake

Oreo cookies, Butter, Cream cheese, Powdered sugar, Milk and 2 more..
Walnut Brownie Loaf W/Cocoa Fudge Frosting

Butter, Sugar, Brown sugar (packed), Vanilla, Eggs and 12 more..
Trifle

Cream cheese, Powdered sugar, Sour cream, Vanilla and 5 more..
Nita's Chocolate Cake

Butter, Shortening, Water, Cocoa, Sugar, Flour, Eggs and 9 more..
Cake Decorating Icing

Butter, Shortening, Powdered sugar (10x), Milk, Vanilla